Agent Photo
Amy Schaefer
Callaway Henderson Sotheby's International Realty
Callaway-Henderson Sotheby's International Realty home
Real Estate Agent

Attention to detail, integrity, and professionalism are the essential hallmarks of Amy Schaefer’s success. She is extremely patient and organized and understands the need for an agent to be a great listener and excellent communicator. Amy brings these skills to every transaction and relationship she develops. She works closely with her clients as a trusted advisor and guides them through the complexities of a real estate transaction from the first conversation through to closing and even beyond. Her savvy knowledge of the current market makes her an invaluable guide, especially in a highly competitive market. She works diligently to make the entire process as organized and stress-free as possible.

Prior to moving to the Princeton area, Amy worked as the Director of Community Relations for the Chicago Symphony Orchestra. Her background in arts management and outreach gives her a savvy awareness and appreciation of our area's diverse populations and cultural offerings. Amy's three children have attended both public and private schools which allows her to offer a unique and helpful perspective for families moving to the area as they weigh their educational options. Her twins currently attend Denison University and her younger son attends Notre Dame High School in Lawrenceville.

Amy can often be found cheering from the sidelines and bleachers at her childrens’ ice hockey and lacrosse games. She enjoys playing tennis, walks along the Delaware Canal, and traveling - especially to her favorite island of Anguilla whenever possible.

Licensed in both New Jersey and Pennsylvania, and now living in Yardley, PA, Amy is uniquely positioned to serve clients in both states.

NJ Realtors® Circle of Excellence Sales Award® 2021

What Some of My Clients Have To Say:

Amy took timely care of every detail with the home readying, helped us understand the market well, supported our decisions, and always, always had our back. She coordinated everything for us and provided a personal touch with all tasks. That gave us the time to focus on our own move and activities. In my years of owning real estate, I’ve yet to meet someone with her combination of utmost professionalism & caring service. - KR, Skillman

Buying a home is tough work and you need to stack the deck in your favor as much as possible. That means having an advocate on your side shepherding you through the process. AMY WAS OUR SHEPHERD. She is truly an expert in her field. Very relaxed, never pushy, and with the patience of a saint. It took my wife and me two years to find our dream home (during the height of COVID) and Amy stuck with us through thick and thin. When it finally came time to put in an offer, she helped us strategize, ultimately beating out 4 other competing offers. Quite an accomplishment in this market. Once our offer was accepted, Amy guided us, first-time home buyers, through the process. She advocated for us every step of the way. She is a consummate professional, super knowledgeable, and uber responsive, even outside of typical office hours. Amy is as cool as a cucumber with a calming presence, which is an important quality during such a stressful and trying time. To this day she remains a trusted source for quality referrals… I would recommend Amy Schaefer to anyone looking to buy or sell a home, she is an absolute pleasure to work with! - MR, Hopewell

Designations/Licenses: Accredited Buyer Representative, Seller Representative Specialist

Amy Schaefer

  • Real Estate Professional
4 Nassau Street
Princeton, New Jersey 08542 United States